Somaliland’s Pursuit of International Recognition:

Somaliland’s Pursuit of International Recognition: A Synthesis of Current Status, Diplomatic Efforts, and Legal Justifications

Introduction:

Somaliland, a self-declared independent state since 1991, continues its efforts to gain international recognition. This document provides a comprehensive overview of Somaliland’s current status, recent diplomatic developments, potential avenues for recognition, and existing obstacles. It also examines the legal arguments supporting Somaliland’s claim to statehood under international law, including the Montevideo Convention, the UN Charter, and the principle of self-determination.

1. Current Status:

Somaliland has been operating as a de facto independent state since 1991, possessing its own government, constitution, currency, military, and electoral system. However, no foreign government currently recognizes it as a sovereign nation.

2. Recent Developments & Diplomatic Efforts:

Momentum Building: Somaliland’s campaign for recognition is gaining traction within Western policy circles. Its stability, governance, and active regional engagement are attracting attention in Washington, Brussels, and London.

Lobbying Efforts: Somaliland’s lobbying activities in the U.S. and Europe have become more organized, involving diaspora groups, advocacy organizations, and engagement with lawmakers.

World Governments Summit: Somaliland’s participation in the World Governments Summit 2025 in Dubai represented a “diplomatic milestone,” aimed at strengthening relationships with potential allies, particularly in the Gulf region.

3. Potential Recognition & Support:

Countries Considering Recognition: Several countries, including the United States, Israel, and the United Arab Emirates, are reportedly in the final stages of reaching an agreement to grant official recognition to Somaliland. Media reports suggest that the U.S., the United Kingdom, Israel, the UAE, and potentially 17 other countries may grant official recognition in the coming months.

U.S. Engagement: The U.S. is engaged with Somaliland on issues such as democratization and economic development. Reports indicate that Somaliland may offer the U.S. a strategic military base along its coastline in exchange for recognition.

UK Support: The UK government demonstrated its support by officially opening a British Office in Hargeisa, Somaliland’s capital, in 2020.

4. Obstacles and Opposition:

Somalia’s Opposition: Somalia maintains that Somaliland remains part of Somalia, as stipulated in the Somali constitution, and actively opposes any moves toward recognition.

U.S. Policy: The official U.S. government policy on Somalia remains unchanged, meaning that the U.S. continues to view Somaliland as being under Somalia’s sovereignty. However, the issue of recognition for Somaliland “remains under regular review”.

5. Somaliland’s Perspective:

President’s Confidence: President Abdirahman Mohamed Abdullahi Irro has expressed confidence that recognition is imminent, suggesting that December 2025 could be a significant turning point.

Strategic Offers: Somaliland is prepared to offer the U.S. a strategic military base at the entrance to the Red Sea, along with a deal for the mining of critical minerals, in exchange for recognition.

6. Legal Justifications for Recognition:

Montevideo Convention:

Criteria for Statehood: The Montevideo Convention of 1933 is a key instrument in international law, outlining the criteria for statehood. Article 1 specifies that a state should possess: (a) a permanent population; (b) a defined territory; (c) a government; and (d) the capacity to enter into relations with other states.

Somaliland’s Compliance: Many international law experts argue that Somaliland fulfills these criteria. It possesses a permanent population, a defined territory based on the former British Somaliland protectorate, a functioning government, and the capacity to engage in diplomatic relations.

Declaratory Theory: The Montevideo Convention embodies the declaratory theory of statehood, suggesting that if an entity meets the criteria, it is a state, regardless of recognition by other states. Article 3 asserts that a state’s political existence is independent of recognition by other states.

UN Charter:

Original Independence: Somaliland gained independence on June 26, 1960, and was recognized by over 30 states, including permanent members of the UN Security Council. Documentation of its independence was submitted to the UN.

Article 4: Meeting the requirements of the UN Charter (Article 4), which states that recognition is a prerequisite for UN membership.

Flawed Union: The subsequent union with Somalia is considered by some to be legally flawed. No treaty of union was properly signed, ratified, or registered with the UN, as required by Article 102 of the UN Charter. Somaliland’s parliament also rejected the act of union in 1961.

Somalia’s Sovereignty: At the time of the union, Somalia was under UN trusteeship and Italian control and lacked the sovereignty to enter into a legal union.

Article 2(4): Somalia’s presence in Somaliland is viewed by some as an illegal occupation under Article 2(4) of the UN Charter, which prohibits territorial expansion by force.

International Diplomacy Law (Geneva/Vienna):

Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties: The Act of Union between Somaliland and Somalia is argued to fall short of the Vienna Convention’s requirements for a valid international treaty.

Diplomatic Engagement: Despite lacking formal recognition, Somaliland has engaged in diplomatic activities, hosting diplomatic offices for several countries and pursuing foreign investment.

Self-Determination:

Right to Self-Determination: Somaliland argues that it has a right to self-determination, particularly given the collapse of the Somali government and the instability in the region.

Unique Circumstances: The African Union has noted that the “union between Somalia and Somaliland was never ratified” and malfunctioned, making Somaliland’s search for recognition “historically unique”.

7. Arguments Against Recognition:

Territorial Integrity: The UN and many international actors prioritize the territorial integrity of Somalia, which hinders recognition of Somaliland.

Potential Domino Effect: There’s concern that recognizing Somaliland could encourage other separatist movements, leading to instability.

Conclusion:

Somaliland’s pursuit of international recognition is gaining momentum, with potential support from several countries. Somaliland’s supporters argue that it meets the criteria for statehood under the Montevideo Convention, that the union with Somalia was legally flawed, and that Somaliland has a right to self-determination due to its stable governance and the collapse of Somalia. However, the international community remains hesitant due to concerns about territorial integrity and regional stability. The outcome of Somaliland’s quest will depend on continued diplomatic efforts, evolving geopolitical considerations, and the interpretation and application of international law.

Prepared by: Dr. Abdilqadir Abdullahi Hassan, Academic Director Al-huda University.

The information contained in the article posted represents the views and opinions of the author and does not necessarily represent the views or opinions commentators. the article a opininian of the author don’t necessarily reflect the Editorial policy of Araweelo News Network.